
The global takaful industry is expected to grow by 20% and reach US$10-15 billion within the next decade, led mainly by the GCC countries and Malaysia.
The global takaful industry is expected to grow by 20% and reach US$10-15 billion within the next decade, led mainly by the GCC countries and Malaysia. In this article, we take a tour of recent developments across the world, as reported by the Middle East Insurance Review.
Despite the absence of truly reliable and up-to-date figures, industry experts agree that the global takaful industry is booming. Depending on whom one speaks to, gross contributions in 2006 ranged between US$2 billion (Ernst & Young) and $5.7 billion (Takaful Re). According to Ernst & Young’s recently-launched World Takaful Report 2008, accepted contributions are expected to rise to more than $4.3 billion in 2010 and that a 20% growth rate of the industry would be maintained.
The drivers of takaful demand include high economic growth and increase in per capita GDP, a youthful demography, increasing awareness, a greater desire for Shariah-compliant offerings and increasing asset-based, Shariah-compliant financing. Despite significant challenges, the outlook for the takaful industry has enthused the Islamic finance world, according to Mr Sameer Abdi, Head of Ernst & Young’s Islamic Finance Services Group. “Assets held and financed by the Islamic financial services industry are increasingly motivated to use takaful to underwrite risk. Existing takaful capacity is slowly replacing conventional insurance in the industry. The challenge for takaful operators lies not only in tapping extrinsic demand but also in developing their capacity and expertise to provide a competitive alternative to conventional insurance,” he said.
While current growth rates indicate a future takaful industry of $10-15 billion within the next 10 years, there are critical factors that must be addressed. Key challenges facing takaful, as outlined by the report, include a fragmented and undercapitalised landscape, limited retakaful capacity, problematic asset management and lack of local solution offerings and local distribution channels.
In addition, the uptake of takaful is still low in Muslim communities. According to Dr Saleh J Malaikah, CEO of SALAMA, it accounts for just 1.1% of the total global insurance premium, whereas the Muslim population makes up 22% of the world’s population. Dr Malaikah has also estimated the number of takaful operators at between 150 and 200. In 2006, they numbered 133, up from 105 the previous year. The market remains concentrated in the GCC and Far East.
According to Ernst & Young’s inaugural World Takaful Report 2008, the GCC is the heart of the global takaful market, with accepted contributions in excess of $1 billion as compared to global contributions of $2 billion in 2006. Of the world total of 133 takaful operators, 59 are within the GCC.
Among the GCC states, Saudi Arabia, the largest economy in terms of GDP with more than a quarter of total Arab GDP, is poised to lead the way. With the implementation of the Cooperative Insurance Companies Law 2003, it has become mandatory for all Saudi insurers to be Shariah-compliant. According to Dr Malaikah, in 2007 alone, 21 operators joined the market and at the end of the year, the insurance business stood at $2.2 billion. This is predicted to more than double in three years. Joining in soon will be takaful giant SALAMA, which is in the process of establishing a $300-million retakaful outfit.
The Kingdom also benefits from its relatively large and wealthy population. More than half of its 25 million population are in the upper middle class or higher, and two thirds are under 30. The insurance industry received an additional boost recently with the introduction of compulsory health insurance for workers and third-party liability motor insurance. Under the new laws, both classes are expected grow in importance and keep pace with the boom in the property sector.
Kuwait now has 11 fully licensed takaful operators. It has also been the launchpad of Al Fajer Retakaful, which has a paid-up capital of $178.5 million and is backed by regional shareholders. In the UAE, Mithaq Lil Takaful, the country’s fourth takaful operator has just completed a successful IPO and is expected to commence operations soon. Takaful Emirates and Noor Takaful, the takaful subsidiary of Noor Islamic Bank are said to be eyeing the market as well.
In Bahrain, t’azur, a new regional takaful company backed by institutional investors from four GCC countries, was formed late last year with an authorised capital of $500 million. The country is also the only one with a dedicated legal framework for takaful.
The number of takaful operators in Qatar has increased, within the last year, to five, following Qatar General Insurance & Reinsurance Co’s launch of its takaful subsidiary. Syria’s three takaful companies intend to launch operations this year, while Oman’s first takaful company operates under the name of Al Madina Gulf Insurance Co.
According to a recent Moody’s report, the potential of the Islamic banking and finance market in Africa is huge. The actual depth of Shariah-compliant financial intermediation was only $18 billion at the end of 2007, equal to a market share of less than 8% of its potential size. More than half of the industry’s assets are located in Sudan, with Egypt ranking second, but with a much lower share of around one-fifth. Mr Anouar Hassoune, analyst and author of the report, said: “Provided that the continent continues to grow at its current pace, which is the fastest in decades, incremental wealth creation will make it easier for the Islamic financial services sector, including Islamic commercial banking but also Shariah-compliant insurance, investment and microfinance, to develop.”
Africa is the birthplace of takaful with Sudan introducing the world’s first general takaful product in 1979. Right now, it is the only country in North Africa to make it compulsory for all insurance businesses to be Shariah compliant. However, despite the long history of takaful in Sudan, the market remains relatively nascent. Insurance premiums reached a total of $171.6 million in 2005, and insurance penetration is only 0.6%.
In Egypt, where Islamic banking and finance companies still lag far behind mainstream commercial institutions, the acceptance of Shariah-based financial solutions remains exceptionally low by standards of the Muslim world. The Egyptian Saudi Insurance House, a provider of general takaful established in 2002, was the first to offer takaful in the country. Five other takaful companies have been licensed, the latest being a joint venture between Japan’s Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire Insurance and Egypt Kuwait Holding Co, which will provide both family and general takaful this year.
Elsewhere in North Africa, takaful investment has been driven by the Salama Group in Tunisia (Best Re), Algeria (Salama Algeria) and Senegal (Salama Senegal). Dr Malaikah has noted signs of interest in the Morocco market, which may lead to the launch of takaful products in the not too distant future. Takaful products were introduced to South Africa last year by Al-Noor Risk Solutions, which is currently riding on the licence of an existing insurer (Lions) and operates on the waqf and wakala models. It expects to obtain a full takaful licence within the next five years.
In the west, Takaful Insurance Co opened in Gambia at the end of 2007. Its Managing Director, Mr Momodou Musa Joof, became acquainted with Islamic insurance in Malaysia and decided to introduce it to Gambia upon his return.
SOUTH ASIA
The dominant takaful markets in this region are Pakistan and Sri Lanka, although India might join the duo soon, if Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance and Parsoli Insurance Broking are successful in obtaining a joint takaful license. Following the introduction of Takaful Rules, Pakistan saw its first general takaful operator, Pak Kuwait Takaful, open in 2005.
Since then, another two general takaful operators, Takaful Pakistan and Pak-Qatar General, and one in family takaful, Pak-Qatar Family Takaful, have commenced operations. The growth of Islamic banking in Pakistan will boost takaful as Islamic banks in Pakistan are required by Shariah laws to insure themselves with a takaful operator.This is creating a huge growth potential, as Islamic banks and financial institutions play an important role in the distribution of takaful products.
Meanwhile, the Pakistani market is grappling with the issue of low awareness and education and as well as ambiguity in regulations. In addition, there is also uncertainty in dealing with the law and a dearth of human resources. The situation is made worse by thin margins, leaving them with relatively little room to manoeuvre. Hence, companies will need to work very hard to ensure that their operations are not just effective, but also very lean.
Takaful entered Sri Lanka only in 2002, when Amana Takaful managed to overcome the tough legal barriers to entry and become the country’s first takaful operator. It was joined soon by Ceylinco Takaful in the latter part of 2006. Takaful accounted for 2.33% of the country’s general insurance market share in 2006, up from 1.71% in 2005. While demand for general takaful products is on the increase, the family takaful segment still needs to be developed.
Home to the largest Muslim population in the world, Asia is a major force in the global takaful market and will continue to play an integral part in the development of the industry. What is more impressive is the short period of time it took to stamp its mark in the industry. The earliest beginnings can be traced back to 1984, when Malaysia introduced the Takaful Act. Through careful planning by a regulator playing the dual roles of driver and enforcer, Malaysia has one of the most advanced takaful markets worldwide and is the undisputed leader of the industry in the Asia continent. It has also become a reference point for takaful globally.
As of 31 May 2007, total net contributions increased 74.6% year-on-year to RM1.27 billion ($401 million), while gross takaful contributions jumped 29.5% to RM717.2 million. Group and investment-linked products (ILPs) seem to be the flavour of the industry, surging by 326.6% and 200.1% year-on-year to RM622.7 million and RM210.4 million, respectively. One of the hot topics facing the industry is the issue of shared services. Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) is actively promoting this initiative that aims to pool together resources of existing takaful companies and outsource them to create economies of scale, particularly in the backend operations such as claims processing and the like.
By the middle of this year, a trial project, which involves outsourcing all aspects of the backend to external parties while takaful operators only sell the product, is expected to finally begin. Currently, about five takaful operators support the initiative. Malaysia is also aggressively trying to court qualified retakaful players to complement and encourage the growthand expansion of the takaful industry. To date, two companies, MNRB and Munich Re, have received retakaful licences from BNM.
In neighbouring Indonesia, takaful only started in the mid-1990s, but there are already 38 takaful operators in the country, up from five just five years ago. This is because most players in the market operate through “windows” which were introduced to encourage more entrants to the lucrative business, and are only required to have a startup capital of only Rp2 billion ($217,000) – a very low and easy figure to meet. Many players, however, lack the finances and resources to operate throughout the sprawling archipelago and instead are limited to operating in major cities such as Yogyakarta, Surabaya, Bandung and Medan, where they will also have to compete with compete with conventional insurers.
The Ministry of Finance (MOF) has raised capital requirements to address the issue. By the end of this year, all full-fledged takaful operators are required to have at least Rp50 billion of capital.
Takaful and retakaful window operators are also required to raise their capital to Rp5 billion and Rp12.5 billion, respectively. This will be increased to Rp25 billion for takaful window operators and Rp50 billion for retakaful window operators by the end of 2010. Joining their ranks soon is PT Asuransi Jiwa Manulife Indonesia, which has indicated that it will be establishing a takaful window early this year. Malaysia-based Maybank is also setting foot into the market after signing a joint venture agreement with PT Anugrah Life Insurance, a subsidiary of PT Panin Life Tbk, to form a family takaful company.An emerging takaful market is Thailand, where at least 15% of its 60 million population are Muslims, mostly residing in the south. Three companies – Dhipaya Insurance, Finansa Life Assurance and Kamol Insurance – provide Islamic insurance, with Kamol being the latest entrant last year. Its president, Mr Manus bin Mahmood, told media that many Thai Muslims had tended to buy insurance products from Malaysia as none of the existing takaful products in the Kingdom were Shariah-compliant. Brunei is another emerging takaful market, albeit a tiny one. In 2005, three takaful operators wrote a gross premium of B$55.3 million ($40.7 million). The Insurance Order and Insurance Regulations 2006 encompassing life and general insurance businesses were passed as part of the ongoing exercise to insurance supervision in line with international best practices. However, there is as yet no legislation to regulate the takaful industry. As commonly practised by countries where takaful legislation is not enacted, the regulatory framework for takaful resembles that of conventional insurance. This makes it difficult for takaful providers to compete with conventional insurers.
The Finance Ministry is working on the Takaful Order to regulate and supervise the takaful industry so that both conventional insurance and takaful will not only be able to compete, but also complement each other as the market is very small.
Britain is set to get its first Shariah-compliant insurance company this year, when British Islamic Insurance Holdings (BIIH) obtains the final approval from the Financial Services Authority (FSA). BIIH will offer car and home insurance initially, with life insurance, investments, savings and ethical financial products to be launched later in the year. In addition, First Takaful also plans to commence its general takaful business in the UK this year. The FSA said that takaful businesses will be regulated as mutual insurance companies and they do not expect to change the accounting rules for takaful operations in the near future.
D-8 is organizing the Second Meeting the Financial Infrastructure for D-8 Countries, in Cairo, Egypt on 4-5 October 2009. “We are encouraging private sectors such as insurance and takaful companies from our member countries, to participate in this event,” said D-8 Secretary General, Dipo Alam. He said that the D-8 member countries should focus more on developments in this sector, such as Syari’ah Banking system, and Islamic Bonds, since they have growned to be a powerful tool in the financial world that even Western, non-Islamic banks are starting to eye for a share on this financial system and plans to assign London as the center for Syari’ah Banks, and Islamic Bonds.
* Participants of the meeting can download the materials for the said meeting by clicking HERE.